Okay let me first state that I do love Modcloth for their extensive selection of hard to find retro, vintage and pin up styled modern clothing. I think they are a great business and i’m impressed by how far they have come in a short period of time. Modcloth does however, have kind of a reputation for jacking up the prices considerably on the same items that other retailers also carry from the same manufacturers. It’s not always obvious since Modcloth rarely states the brand or manufacturer that their items are made by, unless it’s a big name brand.
I am not an expert but I do believe those are the same boots in both stores. Reviews say they run big, so size down if you do end up purchasing them for that amazingly low price of $14.99.